Emmerdale boss responds to fan theory over Caleb's secret

"I've been reading all the theories about who he is."

By Iona Rowan

10 Feb 2023

ITV

Emmerdale spoilers follow.

Emmerdale's executive producer Jane Hudson has responded to the theory that newcomer Caleb is an undercover police officer.

The ITV soap introduced Cain and Chas Dingle's long-lost brother Caleb last year, but his shady behaviour as of late has left some viewers suspicious.

Hudson, however, shut down that particular theory during an appearance on Loose Women yesterday (February 9) – though she did confirm Caleb has a secret that fans are yet to uncover.

"I can tell you he's not an undercover cop," she told the panel. "Coronation Street recently did that story brilliantly with Spider, so we're not going to copy it. So he's not an undercover cop.

"There is a secret about Caleb and the viewers have not yet guessed it. I've been reading all the theories about who he is online."

Last week, Cain finally softened towards Caleb, even suggesting that he spend some time with his son Kyle.

ITV

However, after a kickaround with Kyle, it was confirmed that Caleb was up to no good when he excused himself to take a phone call, telling the mystery caller: "Looks like we're finally making headway. We keep reeling them in until we get exactly what we want."

What is Caleb hiding? Whatever it may be, Hudson recently teased that an imminent twist will stun the entire village, saying: "What's Caleb's involvement with Cain? Does he really want to be Cain's brother or has he got other ulterior motives?

"I think that's a fascinating dynamic to watch – and whenever we have the big house (Home Farm) and the villagers coming together in a story, it's just not going to end well at all."

Emmerdale airs on weeknights at 7.30pm on ITV1, and streams on ITVX.